Presbyopia

Non-Diffractive EDOF IOLs Gaining Ground

Distance and intermediate vision improve with less glare and halos than diffractive alternatives. Howard Larkin reports from the 2022 ASCRS Annual Meeting.

Non-Diffractive EDOF IOLs Gaining Ground
Howard Larkin
Howard Larkin
Published: Friday, August 5, 2022

When it comes to treating presbyopia, non-diffractive extended depth of focus intraocular lens (EDOF IOL) technology is the “new kid on the block,” according to Thomas Kohnen MD, PhD, FEBO. These lenses can reduce optical disturbances such as glare and halos while offering similar depth of focus gains compared with diffractive EDOF and some multifocal IOLs.

For example, in a study Prof Kohnen conducted, 25% of patients implanted with the non-diffractive AcrySof® IQ Vivity™ IOL (Alcon) reported halos compared with rates of 60% to 70% reported for diffractive IOLs.i The non-diffractive Vivity scored better on night visual acuity and produced less glare and halos than the same manufacturer’s PanOptix® trifocal - though the trifocal provided better near visual acuity, he added. Other studies have found bilateral Vivity patients have similar rates of spectacle independence with some diffractive multifocals.ii

MINI-MONOVISION

Implanting the Vivity targeting mini-monovision, with the dominant eye emmetropic and the non-dominant eye at -0.50 D, expanded the effective defocus range, resulting in 87% spectacle independence in a study Prof Kohnen co-authored – comparable to the bilateral PanOptix spectacle independence rate.iii A similar study also showed better near vision targeting -0.25 D to -0.50 D in the non-dominant eye.iv

“You can have an advantage using mini-monovision in these patients,” Prof Kohnen said.

In some studies, diffractive EDOF IOLs deliver similar patientreported quality of vision as similarly designed monofocal lenses. For example, Mini WELL® IOL (SIFI Medtech) uses an engineered aspheric wavefront optic to extend depth of focus, broadening the defocus curve to offer better intermediate and near vision than the same manufacturer’s monofocal Mini 4, with low optical disturbances. Measurements of internal higher order aberrations revealed a greater negative primary spherical aberration in the EDOF group at pupil sizes of 2.0 to 5.0 mm. At 5.0 mm, total internal HOAs did not differ significantly between the two groups.v

While patients tend to be satisfied with their better intermediate and even near vision with any EDOF IOLs, “the basic message always comes to how are these diffractive lenses and other types of lenses actually working in terms of visual disturbances,” Prof Kohnen said. And non-diffractive models may hold the edge.

“I think non-diffractive lenses will be a choice in the future, and mini-monovision with non-diffractive EDOF lenses may make some patients spectacle independent. So, it’s a good choice for patients who want less spectacle dependence after cataract or refractive surgery,” he concluded.

i Kohnen T et al. Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery. 2022 Feb 1; 48(2): 144–150.
ii Hovanesian J et al. Clinical Ophthalmology. 2022 Jan 18; 16: 145–152.
iii Coassin M et al. European Journal of Ophthalmology. 2021 Nov 26; 11206721211064018.
iv van Amelsfort T et al. Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery. 2022 Feb 1; 48(2): 151–156.
v Greve D et al. Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery. 2021 Sep 1; 47(9): 1139–1146.

Thomas Kohnen MD, PhD, FEBO is professor and chair, Department of Ophthalmology, Goethe University, Frankfurt, Germany, and ESCRS treasurer.

A graph showing minimonovision with EDOF #2

Latest Articles
Towards a Unified IOL Classification

The new IOL functional classification needs a strong and unified effort from surgeons, societies, and industry.

Read more...

The 5 Ws of Post-Presbyopic IOL Enhancement

Fine-tuning refractive outcomes to meet patient expectations.

Read more...

AI Shows Promise for Meibography Grading

Study demonstrates accuracy in detecting abnormalities and subtle changes in meibomian glands.

Read more...

Are There Differences Between Male and Female Eyes?

TOGA Session panel underlined the need for more studies on gender differences.

Read more...

Simulating Laser Vision Correction Outcomes

Individualised planning models could reduce ectasia risk and improve outcomes.

Read more...

Mastering IOL Exchange

Tips and tricks for an uncomplicated replacement procedure.

Read more...

Need to Know: Aberrations, Aberrometry, and Aberropia

Understanding the nomenclature and techniques.

Read more...

When Is It Time to Remove a Phakic IOL?

Close monitoring of endothelial cell loss in phakic IOL patients and timely explantation may avoid surgical complications.

Read more...

Delivering Uncompromising Cataract Care

Expert panel considers tips and tricks for cataracts and compromised corneas.

Read more...

Organising for Success

Professional and personal goals drive practice ownership and operational choices.

Read more...